Jan 15 2010
Perhaps the Best Cosplay of the Year: Carl Brutananadilewski

Oh I know Madison’s gonna love this one! I’ve seen attempts at the Carl before. Hell, there’s even a place you can purchase this costume online. But I’m fully convinced that if this guy were actually bald he might really be Carl Brutananadilewski.
Is anyone following ATHF? I feel like it’s one of those shows that you don’t understand why you stopped watching. I mean it’s funny right? Kind of like South Park. Every single time it’s on when I flip through the channels I watch it and yet I don’t DVR it or plan anything around watching it like I might other shows. And yet it’s way better than most stuff on TV.
Anyway, this costume kicks ass.
More Unreal Posts
- My Seven Favorite Supporting Primetime Cartoon Characters of All-Time
- When Adult Cartoon Series Collide
- The Best Trey Parker and Matt Stone Non South Park Projects
- Whoops, I Missed the ‘South Park’ Premiere
- A Gallery of People Dressed Up as Simpsons, Family Guy, and South Park Characters



































ATHF rules.
Gotta give this guy a ton of credit. He knows what he’s suited for.
BTW, perfect description of ATHF. For some reason, I never go out of my way to watch it, and yet I love it. Maybe it’s just one of those things where you’re like, “Meh, I’m usually up at 2:00 am, I’m sure I’ll catch it when it’s on.”
Thank you, Natty, for starting off my weekend the right way.
FRIGGIN’ AWESOME!
I don’t see the “F”oreigner belt buckle.
Carl: Yeah, well, I noticed this long cord comin’ from my house, then I noticed YOUR house, glowin’ like the freakin’ SUN. So I put two and two together and decided – you’re pissin’ me off.
ATHF fans: this guy actually won a contest a year or more ago and got to ACTUALLY play Carl on a live-action episode of the show. Frylock was T-Pain. Shake was Jon Benjamin. Meatwad was an exercise ball.
Didn’t Carl have red hair, and a black mustache…? You also forgot that he usually wore a gold chain around his neck,
All in all though, fantastic cosplay. As soon as I saw the pic I just knew it was Carl, didn’t need any explaining.