Apr 16 2009
Lost Questions: Some Like It Hoth

In this week’s edition of Lost Questions, we tackle the Miles-centric episode, Some Like It Hoth. I’ve always liked Miles personality-wise, but not so much on the whole Sixth Sense front.
So what lingering questions do I want answered after last night?
1) Why the hell can Miles talk to dead people? I wasn’t actually expecting an answer from this episode, but this is one mystery I never wish existed in the first place. The fact that Miles can ghost whisper always felt out of place to me on the show, even with all the other crazy sh*t going on. I guess he’s part of a select contingent of island superheroes along with John “Lazarus” Locke and Walt “Bird Killer” Dawson, but I just don’t know why the creators thought it necessary to even have someone with this power anyways. What is its greater purpose for the show?
2) As I guessed a while back, Miles is actually Chang’s son, and the fact that they’re on the island together proves that worlds won’t collapse if you run into your past self. I understand Miles not remembering seeing himself if he was only a baby when it happened, and his father dies before he grows up, but wouldn’t his mom recognize him? Maybe he just purposefully stays away from her because he realizes that. Or maybe it’s just another plot hole to be fixed via memory loss (*cough* Ben).
3) Hurley clearly still doesn’t grasp the whole “If it happened, it happened” concept. If he wrote Empire Strikes Back and sent it to George Lucas, it would have already happened and he would have seen the changed version growing up right? But that didn’t happen, so his writing is more or less pointless, though it made for a few funny scenes so I’ll allow it.
4) Who was that dead guy? Was he an Other or a Dharma team member? What were they talking about with his tooth going through his brain? What are the Dharma-ites planning with him and presumably other dead people. (Update: I think he had a filling or something in his tooth and some electromagnet (like in the Swan) pulled it through his head).
5) Do you think Chang will die before the gas wipe-out? I don’t remember seeing him among the dead.
6) Do you think one of the future crew will cause “the incident” at the Swan? Or will we be getting out of the ‘70s before then? Do we even have a timetable on when the incident happened?
7) Daniel’s back, complete with two burning questions. Why is he back, and more importantly, when and why did he leave in the first place? It was great to see him though.
8 ) I think my favorite part of the episode was Jack erasing the blackboard. It’s hilarious to see him just chilling doing janitorial work. I think he has no idea what to do now that he’s back and has no position of leadership whatsoever. But presumably he has some special “purpose.” What is it?
9) Again with the “What lies in the shadow of the statue?” refrain. What does that mean, and who were the people who kidnapped Miles? If they were against Widmore, they’re presumably on Ben’s team. And does this mean that the Ajira castaways are on his side too since they apparently know the answer to the statue question? (Update: Bram from the van is packing heat with Ilana on the beach! WTF?)
10) Now that Sawyer has laid Phil out, it would seem that things are going to start unraveling in the ‘70s and covers are about to be blown. How many episodes do you think we have left in the past?
11) Final question. I laugh every time I hear an Ann Arbor or University of Michigan reference because I went there for undergrad. Does anyone know if anyone related to the show has something to do with the University or if that was just a random pick? We don’t exactly have a world renowned theoretical physics department if I remember correctly.
More Unreal Posts




























in answer to #4 – did you not hear that is exactly what happened? miles said his filling came out and went through his head due to the electromagnetic field.
also, we already learned that you can exist in the past with your past self, however just seeing yourself doesn’t cause any issue. some believe (and i am one of them) that the “incident” will result when Miles physically contacts his previous self because it defies all of the quantum physics (rules) they have started to lay down for time travel.
bram and ilana are a 3rd party that are NOT affiliated with Ben, the Others or Widmore. why would you presume they are with Ben? i believe they are working under the direction of Ellie (and Faraday will soon join as he is her son). Faraday obviously has been to the Dharma headquarters in Ann Arbor to explain the time travel issue which is why he was in the “black ops” uniform. he will discuss the Purge with Chang who will most likely make his wife take Miles off the island to save him.
Miles ability to speak with the dead is the entire reason he is on the island and has a very specific purpose.
Despite the fact that an episode was named “Whatever happened, happened”, and Daniel saying it, doesn’t make it so. The writers have been coy with the whole concept and has also brought up the theme of “don’t always believe what you hear/see” within certain eps.
Some groundwork has also been laid, and even mentioned (if I remember correctly), that this whole time travel thing is also possibly “rewriting” history.
But anyhoo, on another note, I’m not totally digging season 5 as I did season 4. It’s still entertaining and worth watching to see how it all ends, but this whole time travel thing has gotten really, well, kinda stupid.
The previous has always focused more on the characters with the island mystery as a backdrop. This season, with the exception of 3-4 episodes, it was allllll about the mythology. It got too plot heavy. This season feels like the plot the is pushing characters instead of the other way around. And when that happens, it becomes contrived, and this season has become that in some parts. Oh well.