We primitive lifeforms called who are -incapable- of traveling past our own satelite(moon) have managed to determine the composition of of planets light years away by analyzing the light spectrums .

But you seem to think that an advanced species capable of intergalactic travel, hell bent on attacking and “harvesting” us failed to notice that 75% our planet’s surface consists of a subtance harmful to them?(And that this substance falls from the sky on a regular basis) Or that the organisms they intend on harvesting are made up mostly of this same substance?

That would be like NASA spending trillions to send an invasion force to a completely unknown, unstudied planet to harvest creatures they know absolutely nothing about.

So either an idiotic storyline or severly brain damaged aliens try to attack earth. Pick one…

Now the author of the list compares the movie with the original source material which was evidently the book. That being so it is actually OUT OF PLACE in this list as the way I read it that is the only movie he compares with the source material. And Sub-Zero rates I am Legend as a terrible movie because of how far it deviates from the book, while none of the others are rated in that fashion that I can see. None of the other movies on the list seem to be compared to any book it may have been based off of.